The responsibility of writing in a divided world

“I don’t see your political piece of writing,” said a friend of mine. “It’s a good area to write about global politics and what is happening in the world politically,” he added. His words lingered in my mind, stirring a quiet debate within myself. Should I venture into the challenging territory of global politics? Could I unravel the intricate weave of ideologies, power struggles, and societal shifts with mere words?

Writing about politics and offering opinions is an intricate endeavour. Where does one begin? Should I start with the First World War of 1914, often referred to as “the war to end all wars,” recounting the tragic loss of millions of lives? Or perhaps I should address the Second World War, which concluded in 1945, reshaping the global order in its aftermath.

Both conflicts left indelible marks on history, shaping the political systems we navigate today. Yet writing about such monumental events demands not only historical accuracy but also a deep understanding of their long-term implications.

Politics influences every facet of human life governance, societal values, and the equitable (or inequitable) distribution of resources. When entrusted to immature or shortsighted politicians, the consequences can be devastating.

History is rife with examples where political mismanagement led to wars, economic crises, and widespread suffering. Thomas Hobbes, in his classic Leviathan (1651), argued that only a strong central authority could prevent chaos and disorder, a state he termed “the war of all against all.”

On the contrary, John Locke advocated for individual liberty and governance through mutual agreement, underscoring the importance of balancing authority and freedom. When this balance tilts, the resulting instability can lead to catastrophic outcomes.

Politics cannot and should not operate solely on emotional grounds. Leaders who manipulate public sentiment to garner support often neglect the structural reforms needed for genuine progress. Niccolò Machiavelli, in The Prince (1513), controversially asserted that successful governance often requires pragmatism over morality. While his perspective is polarising, it highlights the pitfalls of emotionally driven leadership.

Writing about politics demands similar discernment. The writer must approach the subject with clarity, devoid of personal bias, and focus on fostering meaningful dialogue.

One of the greatest challenges in political writing is ensuring the accuracy of information. For instance, take the ongoing conflict between Russia and Ukraine, which began in February 2022. Media coverage, influenced by national and ideological biases, often presents conflicting narratives.

As a writer, one must grapple with these inconsistencies, questioning the authenticity of sources and striving to present a balanced view. Similarly, the Gulf War of 1990–1991, triggered by Iraq’s invasion of Kuwait, remains a contentious subject. While framed as a defence of sovereignty and international order, critics like Noam Chomsky have pointed out the underlying geopolitical and economic motives, particularly the protection of oil interests.

Writing about such events requires not just historical knowledge but also an understanding of the power dynamics at play.

Offering a political opinion carries significant responsibility. It is not merely about sharing thoughts but about considering their potential impact. Words have the power to inspire change or ignite conflict.

A writer must anticipate the ramifications of their work, ensuring it contributes to resolving issues rather than exacerbating them. Jürgen Habermas’ theory of communicative action emphasises the importance of dialogue aimed at mutual understanding. This principle is particularly relevant for political writers, who must ensure their work bridges divides rather than widens them.

The act of writing about politics demands accountability. It requires the writer to rise above sensationalism, rejecting the temptation to oversimplify complex issues. Instead, the focus should be on presenting well-rounded analyses that encourage readers to think critically.

The aim should not be to persuade but to illuminate, providing readers with the tools to form their own informed opinions.

Global politics is a vast and challenging subject. Whether discussing historical events like the World Wars or contemporary issues such as the Russia-Ukraine conflict, the writer bears a heavy burden of responsibility. The goal should not merely be to recount events but to delve into the underlying causes and consequences, drawing lessons that can guide future actions.

Political theorists like Hobbes, Locke, Machiavelli, and Habermas offer valuable frameworks for understanding governance and leadership. Their ideas remind us of the complexities inherent in politics and the need for thoughtful, balanced approaches.

Writing about politics, therefore, is not just about engaging with current events; it is about understanding the human condition and the systems we create to govern ourselves. It is about striving for truth, fostering dialogue, and seeking solutions that lead to a more just and equitable world.

Ultimately, writing about politics is an act of responsibility and courage. It is a commitment to navigating the murky waters of governance, ideology, and human behaviour. It is about raising questions, seeking answers, and using the power of words to contribute to a better, more informed society.